Making Business Development Count in Asian Law Firms

shahid mehmood jbggbq1q5a0 unsplash

Why does law firm business development in Asia so often fall short?

Many law firms in Asia employ capable business development (BD) and marketing professionals, yet relatively few draw the full commercial value from them. This scenario  is seldom the fault of one side alone.

Partners asked to describe the work of their BD team will often mention events, brochures and legal directory submissions. BD professionals, for their part, commonly report that they are consulted too late and not involved in client development. They are also assessed on the volume of their activity rather than on its results. Both the partners’ account and the BD professionals’ account tend to be accurate.

This article is written for both audiences. For lawyers, it considers how firms might make better use of the BD and marketing expertise they already have. For BD and marketing professionals, it sets out what their principal function ought to be and how they may demonstrate their contribution in terms that partners will value.

The short answer: Law firm business development in Asia counts when partners treat BD and marketing professionals as commercial advisers, involving them early, sharing matter and client data, and judging them on instructions won rather than activity. BD professionals, in turn, should frame their work in terms of clients, instructions and revenue, and supply the market intelligence partners cannot gather for themselves.

Key takeaways

  • Partners get more from BD when they involve BD professionals from the start of a pitch opportunity.
  • BD needs access to matter data (records of the firm’s individual client engagements), client revenue, fee arrangements and pipeline information (the work the firm hopes to win) to give sound advice.
  • BD should be measured on instructions won, growth in work from existing clients and new relationships, not on the number of events or legal directory submissions.
  • BD professionals earn credibility by speaking in commercial terms and understanding each practice.
  • Leveraging data and market intelligence are where BD can add the most that partners cannot add themselves.

Why does the relationship between partners and BD falter in Asia?

Several features of the Asian legal market, taken together, tend to confine BD and marketing to a supporting role.

The first feature is the personal nature of client relationships. In many jurisdictions in the region, instructions follow trust built over many years between individual partners and clients. Partners are understandably inclined to regard their own networks as the source of the firm’s work. The difficulty is that a firm built on partners’ personal client relationships may struggle to retain clients when a partner retires or moves on.

The second feature is professional regulation. Rules in several jurisdictions have historically restricted advertising and solicitation by lawyers, India being the most notable example. Where advertising and solicitation rules have since been relaxed, a reluctance to be seen to promote oneself has frequently persisted.

The third feature is the prominence of legal directories. Rankings published by Chambers and Partners, the Legal 500, IFLR1000, Benchmark Litigation and Asian Legal Business are closely followed by clients across the region. Legal directory submissions matter, but in many firms they occupy the greater part of the BD year and leave little capacity for other work. Firms would do well to consider prioritising what directories matter rather than to target everything.

These three features, personal client relationships, professional regulation and the weight of legal directories, reinforce one another. A firm that regards BD as an administrative function will tend to recruit for administrative skills. Staff recruited on that basis are rarely given the opportunity or have the capability to contribute at a strategic level. The partners’ original view of BD as an administrative function is thereby confirmed, and changing the pattern of BD staying in a supporting role requires effort from both parties.

How can partners work with the BD team more effectively?

Partners will obtain the most from their BD colleagues by treating them as commercial advisers rather than as a production resource. In practice, treating BD as commercial advisers calls for several changes in approach.

BD should be involved from the moment a pitch opportunity arises, rather than in the final days before a deadline. Early involvement allows time to research the prospective client, settle the themes of the proposal and consider pricing. Late involvement tends to leave little to do beyond formatting and proofreading. Share the outcome of the pitch opportunity with BD, as a win or a loss will present learning points for both sides.

BD professionals also need access to the information on which sound advice depends, including matter data, client revenue, fee arrangements and the firm’s pipeline. Concerns about confidentiality are legitimate, but confidentiality can generally be managed through appropriate internal controls.

The requests partners make will shape the contribution they receive. A partner who asks for a brochure will receive one. A partner who asks which of the firm’s major clients are receiving less attention than they warrant invites analysis of a far more useful kind. A partner who asks how competitors are positioning themselves in a particular sector invites analysis of the same kind.

The measures used to judge BD’s performance also deserve attention. Instructions won, growth in work from existing clients and new relationships established are better indicators of BD’s contribution than the number of events organised or legal directory submissions filed. Firms looking to set up performance measures for BD can read more on law firm marketing measurement.

Partners should also consider giving BD direct access to clients, for example through structured feedback interviews conducted on the firm’s behalf. Clients are often more candid with an independent interviewer than with the partner who manages their relationship. Or including a BD personnel in a client meeting helps with understanding the client-lawyer dynamics and client needs.

Treating BD as an adviser applies equally to legal directory submissions. A well-run submission process obliges a practice to decide which matters, clients and lawyers best represent it. The decisions about which matters, clients and lawyers to put forward properly belong to the partners, informed by BD’s knowledge of the directory researchers and the wider market.

What is the law firm BD and marketing role, and how can it show its value?

The principal function of a law firm’s BD and marketing team is to help the firm win and retain appropriate work from the clients it most wishes to serve. Events, legal directory submissions, publications and campaigns are means to winning and retaining that work and should be judged accordingly.

Partners assess most matters in terms of clients, instructions, revenue, utilisation (the share of available hours that are billed) and realisation (the proportion of recorded time that is ultimately billed and paid). Proposals framed in terms of clients, instructions, revenue, utilisation and realisation are more likely to receive serious consideration. An event described as an opportunity to meet forty in-house counsel in a target sector, several of whom the firm has never acted for, will carry more weight. An event described as a means of raising the firm’s profile will carry less.

Credibility also depends on a sound understanding of each practice: the work it undertakes, the clients it serves and the sources of its instructions. A BD professional who follows the firm’s deal and case announcements will find partners considerably more receptive. So will a BD professional who appreciates the commercial differences between, say, a restructuring ahead of an initial public offering and a cross-border acquisition.

The contribution partners are least able to make for themselves is market intelligence. Developments among competitors, lateral moves (lawyers joining or leaving firms), changes within clients’ industries and the views of directory researchers and in-house counsel are all within BD’s reach. Partners occupied with client work seldom have time to follow such developments closely.

Legal directory work offers a particular opportunity to supply market intelligence. Those who manage legal directory submissions in Asia and research feedback often have a clearer view than anyone else in the firm of how each practice is perceived. Knowledge of how each practice is perceived by directory researchers and clients can be used to advise partners on where the practice is strong, where its standing may be at risk and which relationships merit further investment.

BD professionals should also keep a record of the outcomes of the work they support, including the pitches in which they were involved and the results of those pitches. Where a firm is slow to involve BD more fully, it is often more effective to begin with a single partner or practice group willing to work differently. A demonstrable success with that partner or practice group can then make the case for involving BD more widely.

What does a good working relationship between partners and BD look like?

Where the relationship between partners and BD works well, partners and BD plan together, share information openly and judge success by the same commercial measures. The head of BD attends practice group meetings, and pitches begin with strategy rather than a template. Legal directory submissions reflect considered decisions about positioning, and client feedback informs the way in which the firm manages its most important relationships.

A partnership between partners and BD can be achieved provided that partners are prepared to include BD in commercial discussions and that BD professionals are equipped to contribute when invited to do so.

Competition for clients in Asia continues to intensify among international firms, regional practices and established domestic firms. Firms that develop their BD and marketing function into a trusted commercial resource are likely to be well placed in the years ahead.

FAQ

  • What is the difference between business development and marketing in a law firm?
    Marketing generally covers the firm’s visible activity, such as publications, events, the website and its legal directory profile. BD focuses on identifying, winning and retaining specific clients and instructions, and includes pitches, client planning and market intelligence. In many firms in Asia a single team covers both, and the line between them matters less than the shared aim of winning and retaining work. The law firm BD and marketing role is easiest to define by the aim of winning and retaining work.
  • What should a firm look for when recruiting a BD professional?
    Look for commercial curiosity and an understanding of how a practice earns its fees, alongside the ability to write well and manage a process. A firm that recruits only for administrative skills will tend to keep BD in an administrative role. It helps to ask candidates how they would measure their own contribution in terms of clients and instructions.
  • How should a firm decide which legal directories to enter?
    Start from where clients and target clients look when choosing counsel, and where competitors are ranked. Weigh the effort each legal directory submission requires against the instructions it is likely to support. Partners should make the final choice, informed by BD’s knowledge of the directory researchers and the market.
  • Can a smaller firm benefit without a dedicated BD team?
    Yes. A smaller firm can apply the principles of early involvement, shared information and measurement by results with one BD professional, or with a partner who takes responsibility for BD. Involve that person early in pitches, share the information they need and judge their work by instructions won rather than activity.
  • Does the approach described here apply to other professional services firms in Asia?
    Personal client relationships and activity-based assessment of BD can appear in many professional services firms, including accounting and consulting practices. The BD teams of those firms can apply the same approach of early involvement, access to information and measurement by commercial results. The regulatory and legal directory points will differ by profession.

How Elevare Asia Can Help

Elevare Asia is a business development and marketing consultancy for law firms and professional services firms, with more than 25 years’ combined experience in legal business development, marketing and strategy across Asia and beyond. Contact our team, visit elevareasia.com or email info@elevareasia.com.

30min
30-minute free consultation
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, serve personalised content and ads, and analyze our traffic. By clicking “Accept All”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can manage your cookie preferences by clicking “Settings”. For more information, please read our [Privacy Policy].